Guide for Reviewers
Thank you for contributing your expertise to the Journal of Research and Review in Science.
1 Accessing the Manuscript
You do not need to create an account to review a paper. When you are assigned a manuscript, you will receive an email containing a secure, unique link.
- Click the "Access Manuscript" button in the email.
- This link logs you into a secure review session automatically.
- You can download the PDF directly from this page.
2 Evaluation Criteria
Please assess the manuscript based on the following key criteria:
Originality & Relevance
Does the paper contribute new knowledge? Is it within the scope of JRRS?
Methodology
Are the methods appropriate, rigorously applied, and clearly explained?
Clarity & Structure
Is the writing clear? Are the abstract, introduction, and conclusion logically connected?
Ethics
Are there any concerns regarding plagiarism, data fabrication, or ethical approval?
3 Submitting Your Report
On the review page, you will find a form to submit your feedback.
- Recommendation: Choose from Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject.
- Comments to Author: Provide constructive feedback. Do not include your name (Double-Blind).
- Confidential Comments: Notes intended only for the Chief Editor.